Whether you’re visiting Indianapolis for a sporting event, a concert, or the Indy 500, where you stay is an important part of the experience. You’re bound to find options all around this sprawling city, not all of which will enhance your trip. That’s why we recommend looking at Airbnb, as the best Airbnbs in Indianapolis have a way of making things easier and helping you see the city in a new light.
To ensure that these vacation rentals in Indianapolis are worth your time, we’ve only included properties with superhosts, and a few are even part of the Airbnb Plus program. Airbnb superhosts are owners with a strong record of well-reviewed accommodations and service, while the Airbnb Plus status indicates that the company has verified the listing’s accuracy with an in-person inspection.
Related: 15 Best Airbnbs in Indiana, USA
2-Bedroom Condo Near Eagle Creek
If you’re seeking vacation apartments for rent in Indianapolis that offer a break from city life, you’ll love this Airbnb. Here in the neighborhood of Cobblestone near Eagle Creek Reservoir, you can enjoy various outdoor activities such as kayaking, sailing, and bird-watching. Despite the relaxed surroundings, you’re only a 15-minute drive from Downtown.
This cozy condo features eclectic decor with a safari vibe. It has two bedrooms that sleep up to four people, with a queen bed in the master bedroom and a single bed and pullout trundle bed in the second room. There’s also a living room with a fireplace and piano, a little study nook, a full bathroom, and a kitchen. Outside, meanwhile, is a relaxing back patio overlooking a small pond.
You can prepare your own meals in the condo’s full kitchen, which has a stove, oven, microwave, fridge, and dishwasher. Other amenities include Wi-Fi, a smart TV, a washer and dryer, free parking, and a complimentary Eagle Creek Park pass.
Studio Apartment in Butler-Tarkington
Easily one of the best Indianapolis Airbnbs, this studio is a great choice if you’re looking for short-term apartment rentals in Indianapolis. The apartment puts you in a pleasant, historic part of the city – Butler-Tarkington, a northside neighborhood home to Butler University.
Although this is a studio apartment above a garage, it can fit up to four people. It has a queen bed and a sofa bed, as well as enough space not to feel cramped when it’s at capacity. Longer stays will be much more comfortable for just one or two guests, though, making this a good option for couples or solo travelers.
You do have everything you could need for a long stay here, including a private bathroom, a kitchen, and free driveway parking. The kitchen is particularly handy, being equipped with a stove, oven, microwave, and fridge. You also have a washer and dryer, cable TV, Wi-Fi, and air conditioning.
Peaceful Farmhouse Apartment Near Downtown
To try something a little different on your trip, consider this Indianapolis Airbnb on the far south side of the city. Staying on a working farm with livestock, you’ll be amazed that you’re only a 10-minute drive from Downtown. That means you can wake up in the countryside and still spend the day or evening in the city with no trouble.
You’ll be staying in an apartment on the lower level of the main farmhouse. It has two bedrooms, one with a queen bed and one with a double bed. You’ll also have a private entrance, living room, full kitchen, and private bathroom. What’s most surprising about this apartment is how modern it looks for part of a farmhouse, thanks to renovations by superhosts Justin and Michelle.
Being on a farm, you’ll want to make the most of your surroundings. You’re free to explore the fields and gardens, even feed the animals. You’ll also have access to communal outdoor spaces, including a fire pit, barbecue grills, and outdoor games such as Giant Jenga, cornhole, and lawn darts. Let’s not forget the in-room amenities either, which include Wi-Fi, a TV with Netflix and a DVD player, a fireplace, a washer and dryer, and air conditioning.
Artistic Condo in Historic Downtown Building
It’s hard to imagine you could rent an apartment in Indianapolis with a better location than this central Airbnb. After all, it’s in the Downtown neighborhood of Mile Square and surrounded by restaurants, with concert venues and museums close by. Whether you visit Indianapolis to attend a concert or sporting event or just for general sightseeing, this location makes it easy.
The condo can sleep up to three people in its two bedrooms, one with a queen bed and one with a double bed. To help you feel at home, it also has a full kitchen off the Zen-like living room, as well as a shared rear courtyard where you can catch some fresh air and quiet.
But it’s the condo’s style that makes it special, which is clear with one look at the vivid murals that decorate its walls. The art, abundant plants, and quirky touches around the apartment create an ideal space for relaxation and inspiration. You certainly won’t be able to tell from the inside that this building is over 100 years old, especially with the various modern conveniences, including Wi-Fi, a high-definition smart TV, a washer and dryer, and air conditioning.
The Farmhouse at Hotel Tango Farms
Another Indianapolis Airbnb that takes you right out of the city is this atmospheric farm stay. You’ll be staying on a 5 acre working farm located just off I-65 in the area of Carson Heights. This highway access does mean you can quickly get to Downtown whenever you like, making a lot less remote than you might think.
One of the big selling points of staying here is how many people this farmhouse can accommodate. With three bedrooms and five beds of various sizes, plus air mattresses on request, it’s possible to fit up to eight adults here. There’s a real flexibility to sleeping arrangements in this Airbnb, meaning it suits most kinds of groups, from large families to group get-togethers. The house also has two full bathrooms, a large full kitchen, a casual dining area, and a living room.
Since it can host large groups, it helps that there’s a gourmet kitchen that’s equipped with an oven, stove, microwave, fridge, and dishwasher. Outside, you have a garage with two car spots, as well as a laundry room for your use. Other amenities include Wi-Fi, TV, keypad entry, and air-conditioning, proving that this farmhouse is not too old-fashioned.
Relax and Spin Vinyl in Upscale Urban Cabin
Among the best Airbnb rentals in Indianapolis is this bright and light-filled home. Situated in the diverse neighborhood of Kennedy King, this Airbnb Plus enjoys a super convenient location and lots of history. While just outside the Downtown area, you’ll find some excellent local spots for coffee, breakfast, and drinks.
Described as an urban cabin, this beautifully restored home has the perfect amount of retro touches to it while still feeling stylish. Thoughtful design choices can be found throughout the house, adding up to give this Airbnb Plus a decidedly upscale quality to it. But not only does this urban cabin look good, it’s also nice and spacious, capable of hosting at most five guests. The sleeping arrangements involve two bedrooms each with a double bed, in addition to a sofa bed in a small common area.
In terms of spaces available to you, the house comes with a living room, study, well-equipped kitchen, laundry room, and two full bathrooms. Outside you have a nice back patio with outdoor furniture, and a private lawn. As for amenities, those include a white noise machine, Wi-Fi, a smart TV with Netflix, air-conditioning, and free on-site parking.
Duplex Bungalow in Broad Ripple Village
For a great local experience in one of the highest-rated Airbnbs in Indianapolis, look no further than this minimalist duplex. It’s out in Broad Ripple Village on the north side of the city, just steps from bars, restaurants, and entertainment – and just a 20-minute drive from Downtown.
With this Airbnb Plus, you’ll have a chic, modern guesthouse to call home while you’re in town. The bungalow has two bedrooms, each with a queen bed, allowing up to four people to stay – though the setup is probably best for two couples rather than a young family. Well-behaved pets can also stay for a fee.
The guesthouse also has a simple living room, a modern kitchen, a full bathroom, and a laundry room. Then there’s the pleasant seating out on the front patio and sun loungers on the back patio, providing ample space for relaxing outdoors in the warmer months. Despite the bungalow’s minimalist look, it’s not light on modern comforts either, offering Wi-Fi, a Roku TV, a dishwasher, air conditioning, free on-site parking, and a self-check-in option.
Private Room in Historic Holy Cross Home
If having an entire place to yourself isn’t that important, you may want to rent a room in Indianapolis instead to save some money. This private room is in the trendy neighborhood of Holy Cross, one of the most livable parts of the city. You can easily reach multiple local breweries and restaurants from here, while Downtown is only 30 minutes away on foot.
You’re sure to feel comfortable here in superhost Michael’s historic, stylishly renovated house, which features some gorgeous original woodwork. It helps that you’ll be sleeping on a king-size Tempur-Pedic mattress in quite a large private room that easily fits two guests. You’ll share a bathroom, though, as well as all the common spaces around the house, including a full kitchen and a backyard.
Your amenities include access to Wi-Fi, cable TV, laundry machines, air conditioning, and on-site parking. Note that Michael has a cat and two dogs, which may be a concern if you have allergies.
Explore Indy from Your Fountain Square House
While there are all sorts of house rentals in Indianapolis to choose from, it’s hard to go past this central, self-contained home. Located close to live music institutions like The HiFi and Radio Radio in Fountain Square, this is a great part of town if you want to sample Indianapolis’ nightlife. You also have a nice selection of restaurants around here, while Downtown is not far away.
This two bedroom house can accommodate four guests and will work best for couples traveling together or younger families. There are queen beds in each bedroom, both of which look nice and cozy, while the living room couches can also be used in a pinch. Elsewhere in the two-storey house there is a small dining table in the living room, a full kitchen, and a full bathroom.
Stepping outside guests can unwind on a private patio and stay warm at night with the in-ground fire pit. Other amenities include a washer/dryer, Wi-Fi, TV, and air-conditioning.
Pvt Room/Entrance in Top Downtown Area Free Parkin
Not all Airbnbs in Indianapolis offering private rooms are just meant for solo travelers or couples. This room for example can sleep up to four guests, making it a super affordable option if you’re visiting Indianapolis on a budget. That’s because this private room comes with a sofa and an air mattress to go with its king bed, which sounds tight, but will certainly work for one night in town.
At this Airbnb you’ll be staying in the home of superhost Jim, which is situated in the neighborhood of Fletcher Place in Downtown Indianapolis. This prime spot means you barely have to step out the front door to have your pick of restaurants, bars, and brunch spots.
Beyond your private room, guests have access to the house’s shared bathroom, the dining room, kitchen, and laundry room. It’s worth noting that you do have a private entrance to your room, as well as a smart TV and desk in the room. Extra perks include Wi-Fi, and access to Jim’s board game library.
Romantic Loft in Broad Ripple Village
This stunning loft oozes style and is a great choice for an intimate couples getaway. Staying in Broad Ripple Village on the city’s north side, you’ll be treated to some wonderful local bars, restaurants, and shops. If you choose to leave this fun neighborhood, you’ll only have to drive 20 minutes to reach Downtown.
With just a queen bed, this Airbnb Plus is meant for couples or solo travelers. There’s really no barrier between the bedroom and the bathroom, leaving little in the way of privacy between you and your travel companion. Considering that and the big soaking tub, it’s clear that the loft has mainly romantic getaways in mind.
That’s not to say it’s short on space for a loft, with a large open-plan area outside the bedroom. There you have an inviting living room, a study area, and a full kitchen that should give you everything you need for a pleasant stay. Dining in won’t be a problem, thanks to the full kitchen with a microwave, stove, oven, fridge, dishwasher, and breakfast bar. Further amenities include a washer and dryer, Wi-Fi, a Roku TV, air conditioning, and a self-check-in option.
Private Guest Suite in Historic Fletcher Place Home
If you are visiting for a sporting event or concert and need an Airbnb in Downtown Indianapolis, consider this quaint purple home in the historic neighborhood of Fletcher Place. You couldn’t ask for a better part of the city to stay in, with local restaurants and breweries as well as the sights of Downtown nearby, not to mention the nightlife in neighboring Fountain Square.
You’ll be staying in a shotgun-style unit that takes up half of a historic house. It sleeps up to five guests, with a king bed in the bedroom, a comfortable sofa, and an air mattress. For an extra fee, you can even bring housetrained pets.
The bedroom is upstairs, while the living room, dining room, kitchen, and full bathroom are all downstairs. You can also hang out on the front porch and back deck. In case you want to cook, the kitchen includes a stove, oven, microwave, fridge, and dishwasher. The unit also offers Wi-Fi, TV, air conditioning, free parking, and a washer and dryer.
Pet-Friendly SoBro Duplex for Large Groups
With a gorgeous sense of style and plenty of space, this is one of the larger Indianapolis Airbnbs you’ll come across. You’ll be staying in the northside neighborhood of South Broad Ripple (also known as SoBro), just a short walk away from local eateries, shops, and the Monon Trail. Downtown isn’t far either, just an easy 10-minute drive.
The main selling point of this duplex is its suitability for large groups. Up to eight people can sleep here, with queen beds in each of the three bedrooms and a plush sofa in the living room. The unit as a whole has plenty of space, with an inviting living room, a cozy sunroom, a kitchen, a dining room, and 1.5 bathrooms.
In case all that’s not enough, there’s also a balcony and an enclosed backyard, complete with a fire pit and barbecue grill, for time outside during the warmer months. The backyard is especially useful if you bring pets, which are welcome! You also get Wi-Fi, a Roku TV, air conditioning, laundry machines, and an indoor fireplace.
Cozy 2-Bedroom Bungalow in SoBro
This cool bungalow in a friendly part of town is hard not to like. As another house in the popular southern reaches of Broad Ripple, it provides easy access to local cafes, restaurants, and gastropubs.
Like many homes in this neighborhood, this Airbnb is a cozy bungalow with a modern, well-appointed interior. With a queen bed in the master bedroom, a double bed in the other bedroom, and a travel crib, it’s a good pick for young families or two couples vacationing together. There’s also a pleasant living room, a full kitchen, a dining area, and 1.5 bathrooms.
You get a nice amount of outdoor space on this property, with a large deck and a backyard at your disposal, as well as a two-car garage. Other amenities include a laundry room, air conditioning, Wi-Fi, and a smart TV.
Clean & Comfy Vintage Mod Carriage House Downtown
When comfort is a key requirement for your Indianapolis vacation, places like this are where you should focus your attention. Located in the friendly Kennedy King neighborhood just north of Downtown, this apartment puts you close to the city’s sights, while also providing some local flavor.
Built above the garage of superhost Rob’s home, this Airbnb is a carriage house apartment meant for three people. It comes with just one bedroom that has a queen bed, plus a twin air mattress or couch available for a third person. Realistically though, this apartment seems best suited to single travelers or couples, although there is enough space for three people. That’s thanks to the open-plan layout of the living room/kitchen, where you’ll also find a small dining table.
While the whole apartment has clearly been carefully renovated, its galley kitchen stands out as particularly modern. There you have a stove, oven, microwave, fridge, and dishwasher at your disposal, allowing you to prepare your own meals if you want. Extra amenities here include a washer/dryer, Wi-Fi, smart TV, keypad entry, driveway parking spot, and air-conditioning.
No matter how long you plan to visit, we’re sure these Airbnbs in Indianapolis will help you make the most of your time there!
Leave a Reply